259 - Electric or Acoustic? Which Guitar Should You Learn On?

In this episode, Paul Andrews tackles one of the most common questions among beginner guitarists: Should you start learning on an electric or acoustic guitar?

Drawing from his experience, student feedback, and a recent question from a listener named Glenn, Paul dives deep into the practical differences between electric and acoustic guitars, debunks myths, and helps you figure out the best instrument to start your own guitar journey.

Beginner Guitar Academy News

• Monthly Academy show roundup: Celebrating student progress, guitar-versaries, and highlights from the past month.
• New club blogs for each student level offer extra resources and support, including in-depth riff breakdowns and practice checklists.
• Upcoming events:

Sip and Strum (Nov 16th): Learn a song (Zombie by The Cranberries) together, suitable for all levels, including advanced techniques and tone discussion.

Live Q&A (Nov 24th): Submit questions beforehand or join live; recordings will be uploaded to the Academy and member-only podcast.

Electric vs Acoustic: The Basics

• Acoustic guitars are self-contained, portable, and great for rhythm and singer-songwriter styles.
• Electric guitars are more comfortable (lighter strings, slimmer necks), but require extra equipment like amps, cables, and headphones.

Pros and Cons

• Electric Guitar Pros: Easier to play, versatile across genres with effects pedals, smaller neck—ideal for players with small hands.
• Electric Guitar Cons: Need for extra gear and a steeper learning curve for total beginners.
• Acoustic Guitar Pros: Simple, portable, perfect for social situations and spontaneous play.
• Acoustic Guitar Cons: Heavier strings, higher action, wider necks—can be tougher for beginners.

Choosing the Right Guitar

• The best guitar is the one that inspires you and matches your musical tastes.
• If you want to play Ed Sheeran or Taylor Swift, start with an acoustic; if you dream of playing Hendrix or Metallica, electric makes more sense.
• Both instruments teach the foundational skills of guitar playing – chords, scales, strumming, picking – and Beginner Guitar Academy’s early levels apply to both.
• When advancing to lead guitar, effects, and tone control, an electric guitar becomes necessary.

Cost & Gear Tips

• You don’t need to spend a lot. Consider second-hand guitars on Facebook Marketplace, eBay, or UK sites like gear4music.com for affordable, quality options.

Final Advice

• Consistent practice, structure, and accountability matter more than which guitar you choose.
• Transitioning between acoustic and electric is easy – many students eventually own both.
• Don’t let indecision stall your progress; start with the guitar that excites you!

Quick Takeaways

• Both acoustic and electric guitars are excellent for beginners.
• Choose the guitar that fits your musical inspiration and goals.
• Structure and commitment trump gear choice.
• Beginner Guitar Academy is designed to help you succeed regardless of the type of guitar you start with.

Subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode with anyone starting their guitar journey!

For more details or to sign up for the trial, visit beginnerguitaracademy.com.

See you next week for another episode!